<?xml version='1.0' encoding='utf-8'?>
<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Publishing DTD v1.2 20190208//EN" "http://jats.nlm.nih.gov/publishing/1.2/JATS-journalpublishing1.dtd">
<article article-type="research-article" dtd-version="1.2" xml:lang="ru" xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><front><journal-meta><journal-id journal-id-type="issn">2313-8912</journal-id><journal-title-group><journal-title>Research Result. Theoretical and Applied Linguistics</journal-title></journal-title-group><issn pub-type="epub">2313-8912</issn></journal-meta><article-meta><article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.18413/2313- 8912-2025-11-2-0-1</article-id><article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">3792</article-id><article-categories><subj-group subj-group-type="heading"><subject>THEORY OF LANGUAGE</subject></subj-group></article-categories><title-group><article-title>&lt;strong&gt;A Comparative Reading of Pāṇinian Grammatical Tradition and Modern Science of Speech&lt;/strong&gt;</article-title><trans-title-group xml:lang="en"><trans-title>&lt;strong&gt;A Comparative Reading of Pāṇinian Grammatical Tradition and Modern Science of Speech&lt;/strong&gt;</trans-title></trans-title-group></title-group><contrib-group><contrib contrib-type="author"><name-alternatives><name xml:lang="ru"><surname>Dwivedi</surname><given-names>Prabha Shankar</given-names></name><name xml:lang="en"><surname>Dwivedi</surname><given-names>Prabha Shankar</given-names></name></name-alternatives><email>prabhas.dwivedi@bhu.ac.in</email><xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff1" /></contrib><contrib contrib-type="author"><name-alternatives><name xml:lang="ru"><surname>Singh</surname><given-names>Atul Kumar</given-names></name><name xml:lang="en"><surname>Singh</surname><given-names>Atul Kumar</given-names></name></name-alternatives><email>atulksinghh@gmail.com</email><xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff2" /></contrib></contrib-group><aff id="aff1"><institution>Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, India</institution></aff><aff id="aff2"><institution>Jaypee University of Information Technology, Himachal Pradesh, India</institution></aff><pub-date pub-type="epub"><year>2025</year></pub-date><volume>11</volume><issue>2</issue><fpage>0</fpage><lpage>0</lpage><self-uri content-type="pdf" xlink:href="/media/linguistics/2025/2/Лингвистика-4-22.pdf" /><abstract xml:lang="ru"><p>The modern history of Western linguistics began with comparative philology and coincided with the colonisation of the East for a long time. The colonisation as a process not only involved an interplay of power, dominance and state, it was also a conquest of knowledge. Colonies such as India had a vast rubric of ancient knowledge and especially excelled in linguistics and philology. This paper is an attempt to showcase how the roots of various phonetic and phonological theories that defined and dominated modern linguistics were linked to the ancient Indian grammatical tradition. Scholars from Pāṇinian School of Grammar, such as Pāṇini, Kātyāyana, Pata&amp;ntilde;jali, and Bhartṛhari, have explained a range of speech phenomena to which modern phonetics and phonology correspond significantly. This paper analyses the common grounds between prominent schools of Western phonology and their Indian counterparts and thus highlights a significant theoretical overlap between the knowledge offered by the Western linguistic schools and what was explained several centuries back by prominent Indian grammarians. From the linking of sounds to the psychological reality of a phoneme, the vast canvas of the Indian linguistic tradition could be verifiably seen as a precursor to the most of the structural turn in the twentieth century. Finally, the paper attempts to show the precedence of various recent concepts and theories, such as &amp;lsquo;distinctive feature theory&amp;rsquo; or &amp;lsquo;generative grammar&amp;rsquo; in the texts like&amp;nbsp;Aṣṭādhyāyī&amp;nbsp;and&amp;nbsp;Vākyapdīya.</p></abstract><trans-abstract xml:lang="en"><p>The modern history of Western linguistics began with comparative philology and coincided with the colonisation of the East for a long time. The colonisation as a process not only involved an interplay of power, dominance and state, it was also a conquest of knowledge. Colonies such as India had a vast rubric of ancient knowledge and especially excelled in linguistics and philology. This paper is an attempt to showcase how the roots of various phonetic and phonological theories that defined and dominated modern linguistics were linked to the ancient Indian grammatical tradition. Scholars from Pāṇinian School of Grammar, such as Pāṇini, Kātyāyana, Pata&amp;ntilde;jali, and Bhartṛhari, have explained a range of speech phenomena to which modern phonetics and phonology correspond significantly. This paper analyses the common grounds between prominent schools of Western phonology and their Indian counterparts and thus highlights a significant theoretical overlap between the knowledge offered by the Western linguistic schools and what was explained several centuries back by prominent Indian grammarians. From the linking of sounds to the psychological reality of a phoneme, the vast canvas of the Indian linguistic tradition could be verifiably seen as a precursor to the most of the structural turn in the twentieth century. Finally, the paper attempts to show the precedence of various recent concepts and theories, such as &amp;lsquo;distinctive feature theory&amp;rsquo; or &amp;lsquo;generative grammar&amp;rsquo; in the texts like&amp;nbsp;Aṣṭādhyāyī&amp;nbsp;and&amp;nbsp;Vākyapdīya.</p></trans-abstract><kwd-group xml:lang="ru"><kwd>Phonetics</kwd><kwd>Pāṇinian grammar</kwd><kwd>modern linguistics</kwd><kwd>speech</kwd><kwd>Aṣṭādhyāyī</kwd><kwd>Śikṣā</kwd></kwd-group><kwd-group xml:lang="en"><kwd>Phonetics</kwd><kwd>Pāṇinian grammar</kwd><kwd>modern linguistics</kwd><kwd>speech</kwd><kwd>Aṣṭādhyāyī</kwd><kwd>Śikṣā</kwd></kwd-group></article-meta></front><back><ref-list><title>Список литературы</title><ref id="B1"><mixed-citation>Abercrombie,&amp;nbsp;D. (1949). What is a &amp;ldquo;letter?&amp;rdquo;, Lingua, 2, 54&amp;ndash;63. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B2"><mixed-citation>Allen,&amp;nbsp;W.&amp;nbsp;S. (1953). Phonetics in Ancient India, Oxford University Press, London. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B3"><mixed-citation>Anderson,&amp;nbsp;S.&amp;nbsp;R. (2021). Phonology in the Twentieth Century, Language Science Press, Berlin. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B4"><mixed-citation>Atherton,&amp;nbsp;M. (1994). Henry Sweet&amp;rsquo;s Idea of Totality: A Nineteenth Century Philologist&amp;rsquo;s Approach to the Practical Study of Language, D. Phil. Thesis, University of York, York, England. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B5"><mixed-citation>Pataskar,&amp;nbsp;B. (2016). Philosophy of Language as Reflected in the Nirukta of Yāska, Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute, 97, 143&amp;ndash;149. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B6"><mixed-citation>Barbieri,&amp;nbsp;C., Blasi,&amp;nbsp;D.&amp;nbsp;E., Arango-Isaza,&amp;nbsp;E., Sotiropoulos,&amp;nbsp;A.&amp;nbsp;G., Hammarstr&amp;ouml;m,&amp;nbsp;H, Wichmann,&amp;nbsp;S., Greenhill,&amp;nbsp;S.&amp;nbsp;J., Gray,&amp;nbsp;R.&amp;nbsp;D., Forkel&amp;nbsp;R., Bickel,&amp;nbsp;B. and&amp;nbsp;Shimizu,&amp;nbsp;K.&amp;nbsp;K. (2022). A Global Analysis of Matches and Mismatches between Human genetic and Linguistic Histories,&amp;nbsp;Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 119&amp;nbsp;(47), 1&amp;ndash;9. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2122084119 (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B7"><mixed-citation>Blancke,&amp;nbsp;S. and Denis,&amp;nbsp;G. (2018). Bringing Darwin into the social sciences and the humanities: cultural evolution and its philosophical implications, History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences,&amp;nbsp;40&amp;nbsp;(2), 1&amp;ndash;12. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B8"><mixed-citation>Buitenen,&amp;nbsp;J.&amp;nbsp;A.&amp;nbsp;B.&amp;nbsp;v. (1959). Akṣara, Journal of the American Oriental Society, 79 (3), 176&amp;ndash;187. DOI: 10.2307/595087 (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B9"><mixed-citation>﻿Buitenen,&amp;nbsp;J.&amp;nbsp;A.&amp;nbsp;B.&amp;nbsp;v. (1955). ﻿Notes on Akṣara, ﻿Bulletin of the Deccan College Post-Graduate and Research Institute, 17 (3), 204&amp;ndash;215. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B10"><mixed-citation>Bloomfield,&amp;nbsp;L. (1957). Language, George Allen and Unwin Ltd, London. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B11"><mixed-citation>Bronkhorst,&amp;nbsp;J. (1998). Indian theories of Language, Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Taylor and Francis. DOI: 10.4324/9780415249126-F048-1 (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B12"><mixed-citation>Cardona,&amp;nbsp;G. (1969). Studies in Indian Grammarians. I. The Method of Description Reflected in the Śivasūtras, Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, 59 (1), 3&amp;ndash;48. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B13"><mixed-citation>Colas-Chauhan,&amp;nbsp;U. (2008). A Śaiva Theory of Meaning, Journal of Indian Philosophy, 36&amp;nbsp;(4), 427&amp;ndash;453. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B14"><mixed-citation>Dasgupta,&amp;nbsp;S. (trans.) (1991). The Mahabhasya of Pata&amp;ntilde;jali, Indian Council of Philosophical Research, New Delhi. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B15"><mixed-citation>Deshpande,&amp;nbsp;M.&amp;nbsp;M. (2001). Ancient Indian Phonetics, in Creidler,&amp;nbsp;Cherles&amp;nbsp;W.&amp;nbsp;(ed.) Phonology: Critical Concepts, Routledge, London and New York, I, 7&amp;ndash;17. (In English) https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-042580-1.50014-3</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B16"><mixed-citation>Deshpande,&amp;nbsp;M.&amp;nbsp;M. (1989). Review of Aṣṭādhyāyī of Pāṇini by Sumitra M. Katre, Language, 65 (3), 646&amp;ndash;648. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B17"><mixed-citation>Deshpande,&amp;nbsp;M.&amp;nbsp;M. (1994&amp;ndash;95). Pāṇini and the Distinctive Features, Bulletin of the Deccan College Post-Graduate and Research Institute, 54/55 (Sir William Jones Volume Commemorating the Bicentenary), 87&amp;ndash;97. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B18"><mixed-citation>Deshpande,&amp;nbsp;P. (2010&amp;ndash;11). Comparative Study of Technical Terms in Vopadeva&amp;rsquo;s Mugdhabodha Grammar, Bulletin of the Deccan College Post-Graduate and Research Institute, 70/71, 409&amp;ndash;418. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B19"><mixed-citation>Dowson,&amp;nbsp;J. (1888). A Classical Dictionary of Hindu Mythology and Religion, Geography, History, and Literature, Trubner &amp;amp; Co, London. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B20"><mixed-citation>Dresher,&amp;nbsp;B.&amp;nbsp;E. (2011). The Phoneme, in Oostendorp,&amp;nbsp;M., Ewen,&amp;nbsp;C.&amp;nbsp;J., Hume,&amp;nbsp;E. and Rice,&amp;nbsp;K. (ed.) The Blackwell Companion to Phonology. DOI: 10.1002/9781444335262.wbctp0011 (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B21"><mixed-citation>Manjali,&amp;nbsp;F. (2012). The &amp;lsquo;Social&amp;rsquo; and the &amp;lsquo;Cognitive&amp;rsquo; in Language: A Reading of Saussure, and Beyond, Texto!, 17&amp;nbsp;(3), 1&amp;ndash;15. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B22"><mixed-citation>Folgado,&amp;nbsp;M.&amp;nbsp;J.&amp;nbsp;G., Fern&amp;aacute;ndez de Gobeo D&amp;iacute;az de&amp;nbsp;Durana,&amp;nbsp;N., Ram&amp;iacute;rez Luengo,&amp;nbsp;J.&amp;nbsp;L., Rodr&amp;iacute;guez,&amp;nbsp;E.&amp;nbsp;A., Ortega-Santos,&amp;nbsp;I. and Polo Cano,&amp;nbsp;N. (2020). Language and Linguistics, The Year&amp;rsquo;s Work in Modern Language Studies, 80, 313&amp;ndash;339. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B23"><mixed-citation>Ghosh, M. (1938). Pāṇinīya Śikṣā: Or, The Śikṣā Vedaṅga Ascribed to Pāṇini, The University of Calcutta, Calcutta. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B24"><mixed-citation>Ghosh,&amp;nbsp;A. and Kiparsky,&amp;nbsp;P. (2019). Perspective: The Grammar of the Elements,&amp;nbsp;American Scientist, 107&amp;nbsp;(6), 350&amp;ndash;355. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B25"><mixed-citation>Gillon,&amp;nbsp;B.&amp;nbsp;S. (2007). Pāṇini&amp;rsquo;s &amp;lsquo;Aṣṭādhyāyī&amp;rsquo; and Linguistic Theory, Journal of Indian Philosophy, 35 (5/6), 445&amp;ndash;468. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B26"><mixed-citation>Gleason,&amp;nbsp;H.&amp;nbsp;A. (1961). An Introduction to Descriptive Linguistics, Holt, Rinehart &amp;amp; Winston, Canada. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B27"><mixed-citation>Halle,&amp;nbsp;M., and Clements,&amp;nbsp;G.&amp;nbsp;N. (1983). Problem Book in Phonolohy: A Workbook for Introductory Courses in Linguistics and in Modern Phonology, MIT Press. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B28"><mixed-citation>Holdcroft,&amp;nbsp;D. (1991). Saussure: Signs, System, and Arbitrariness, Cambridge University Press. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B29"><mixed-citation>Houben,&amp;nbsp;J.&amp;nbsp;E.&amp;nbsp;M. (1989&amp;ndash;90). The Sequencelessness of the Signifier in Bhartṛhari&amp;rsquo;s Theory of Language, Indologica Taurinensia, 15&amp;ndash;16, 119&amp;ndash;129. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B30"><mixed-citation>Jakobson,&amp;nbsp;R. (1978). Six Lectures on Sound and Meaning, Translated by J.&amp;nbsp;Mepham, Harvester Press. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B31"><mixed-citation>Jones,&amp;nbsp;D. (1969). An Outline of English Phonetics: with 116 Illustration: and with Appendices on &amp;ldquo;Types of Phonetic Transcription&amp;rdquo; and &amp;ldquo;American Pronunciation&amp;rdquo;, W. Heffer &amp;amp; Sons Ltd, Cambridge. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B32"><mixed-citation>Jones,&amp;nbsp;W. (1788). Asiatick Researches &amp;ndash; I, Asiatick Society, Calcutta. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B33"><mixed-citation>Joseph,&amp;nbsp;J.&amp;nbsp;E. (2012). Saussure, Oxford University Press, Oxford. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B34"><mixed-citation>Joshi,&amp;nbsp;S.&amp;nbsp;D., and Roodbergen, J.&amp;nbsp;A.&amp;nbsp;F. (1995). The Aṣṭādhyāyī of Pāṇini, Sahitya Akademi, New Delhi. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B35"><mixed-citation>Koerner,&amp;nbsp;E.&amp;nbsp;F.&amp;nbsp;K. (1993). Historiography of Phonetics: The State of the Art, Journal of the International Phonetic Association, 23&amp;nbsp;(1), 1&amp;ndash;12. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B36"><mixed-citation>Laver,&amp;nbsp;J. (1994). Principles of Phonetics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B37"><mixed-citation>Li,&amp;nbsp;C. (2018). Sounding out Diff&amp;eacute;rance, Philosophy East and West, 68, 2, 447&amp;ndash;459. DOI: 10.1353/pew.2018.0040&amp;nbsp;(In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B38"><mixed-citation>Łucyszyna,&amp;nbsp;O. (2016). Classical Sāṁkhya on the Relationship between a Word and Its Meaning, Journal of Indian Philosophy, 44&amp;nbsp;(2), 303&amp;ndash;323. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B39"><mixed-citation>Matilal,&amp;nbsp;B.&amp;nbsp;K. (2017). Logic, Language and Reality: Indian Philosophy and Contemporary Issues, Motilal Banarsidass Publishers Private Limited, New Delhi. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B40"><mixed-citation>Nelson,&amp;nbsp;S., (2022). A Model Theoretic Perspective on Phonological Feature Systems, Society for Computation in Linguistics, 5&amp;nbsp;(1), 1&amp;ndash;9. DOI:&amp;nbsp;10.7275/G77n-Za52 (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B41"><mixed-citation>Patterson,&amp;nbsp;J. (2023) William Jones and the Study of Hinduism,&amp;nbsp;Global Intellectual History, 10&amp;nbsp;(2), 109&amp;ndash;117. DOI: 10.1080/23801883.2023.2184408 (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B42"><mixed-citation>Pillai,&amp;nbsp;K.&amp;nbsp;R. (trans.) (1971). The Vākyapadīya: Critical Text of Cantos I and II, Motilal Banarsidass, New Delhi. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B43"><mixed-citation>Sagey,&amp;nbsp;E. (1986). The Representation of Features in Non-Linear Phonology, Routledge. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B44"><mixed-citation>Saussure,&amp;nbsp;F.&amp;nbsp;de. (1959). Course in General Linguistics, Translated by Wade Baskin, and edited by Charles Bally and Albert Sechehaye, Philosophical Library, New York. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B45"><mixed-citation>Sharma,&amp;nbsp;R.&amp;nbsp;N. (2000). The Aṣṭādhyāyī of Pāṇini Vol.&amp;nbsp;II, Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers, New Delhi. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B46"><mixed-citation>Staal,&amp;nbsp;J.&amp;nbsp;F. (1962). A Method of Linguistic Description: The Order of Consonants According to Pāṇini, Language, 38&amp;nbsp;(1), 1&amp;ndash;10. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B47"><mixed-citation>Stawarska,&amp;nbsp;B. (2020) Saussure&amp;rsquo;s Linguistics, Structuralism, and Phenomenology: The Course in General Linguistics after a Century, Palgrave Macmillan, London. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B48"><mixed-citation>Stewart,&amp;nbsp;I. (2023) William Jones&amp;rsquo; Legacy in Britain: Philology, Mythography, Ethnology, Global Intellectual History, 10&amp;nbsp;(2), 149&amp;ndash;157. DOI: 10.1080/23801883.2023.2184406 (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B49"><mixed-citation>Subramania Iyer,&amp;nbsp;K.&amp;nbsp;A. (1965). Bhartṛhari on Dhvani, Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute, 46&amp;nbsp;(1/4), 49&amp;ndash;65. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B50"><mixed-citation>Subrahmanyam,&amp;nbsp;K. (1992). The Vākyapadīyam of Bhartṛhari: Brahmakanda, Sri Satguru Publications, New Delhi. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B51"><mixed-citation>Sweet,&amp;nbsp;H. (1877). A Handbook of Phonetics Including a Popular Exposition of the Principles of Spelling Reform, Clarendon Press, Oxford. &amp;nbsp;(In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B52"><mixed-citation>Sweet,&amp;nbsp;H. (1900). The History of Language, J. M. Dent and Sons, London. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B53"><mixed-citation>Twaddell,&amp;nbsp;W.&amp;nbsp;F. (1935). On Defining the Phoneme, Language, 1, 5&amp;ndash;62. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B54"><mixed-citation>Varma,&amp;nbsp;S. (1961). Critical Studies in the Phonetic Observations of Indian Grammarians, Vol.&amp;nbsp;VIII, Munshi Ram Manohar Lal, New Delhi.</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B55"><mixed-citation>Wrenn,&amp;nbsp;C.&amp;nbsp;L. (2002). Henry Sweet (1845-1912), in Portrait of Linguists: A Biographical Source Book for the History of Western Linguistics (1746-1963), Vol.&amp;nbsp;1, edited by T.&amp;nbsp;A.&amp;nbsp;Sebeok, Theommes Press, Bristol, 512&amp;ndash;32. (In English)</mixed-citation></ref><ref id="B56"><mixed-citation>Zwirner,&amp;nbsp;E. (1966). Bemerkungen zur Geschichte der Phonetik, in Zwirner, E.&amp;nbsp;and K. Grundfragen der Phonometrie, S. K, Basel, 17&amp;ndash;110. (In German)</mixed-citation></ref></ref-list></back></article>